Checkr vs Sterling: Which Background Check Provider Offers More for Employers?

Recruiter reviewing a candidate file on a clipboard, checkr vs sterling for employers

Hiring teams rarely get to test two screening vendors side by side, so the choice usually comes down to what each one publishes. This look at checkr vs sterling compares the two on screening range, technology and support for employers. It also covers a change that matters to buyers: Sterling is now part of First Advantage.

This is an independent editorial review. Checkr did not review or approve this article, and other brands are named only as reference points.

Comparison table: Checkr and Sterling

Point Checkr Sterling
Ownership Standalone company A First Advantage company since the deal closed in October 2024
Core focus Technology-led screening with AI-assisted review Broad screening and identity services for regulated and global hiring
Packages Basic, Essential, Complete and Enterprise tiers listed online Programs shaped around industry and role through sales
Integrations 200+ pre-built HR system integrations stated Integrations and an API listed on its site
International Checks in 200+ countries and territories stated Global checks and global screening solutions listed
Post-hire Continuous checks with record alerts Criminal, driving record and medical license monitoring
Onboarding extras Form I-9 among the add-ons Form I-9 and E-Verify

What checkr vs sterling means after the First Advantage deal

Any review of checkr vs sterling has to start with ownership. First Advantage completed its purchase of Sterling on October 31, 2024. Sterling’s own site now carries a banner saying it is a First Advantage company and points visitors to the parent’s site. Its services are still listed, so existing customers can keep using them, yet new buyers should ask which platform, contract and support team they would actually get.

Checkr remains a standalone company. It says more than 140,000 businesses use its products, which now reach beyond hiring into tenant, mortgage and insurance screening.

Choosing a background check provider by hiring volume

The right background check provider depends on how you hire. Checkr lists three self-serve packages plus an Enterprise tier, so a small team can see what each level covers before speaking to anyone. Sterling has long sold to mid-size and large employers in fields such as healthcare, financial services, staffing and transportation, where screening programs are tailored per role.

  • Small teams often value published packages and quick setup.
  • Regulated employers usually need role-based programs and audit trails.
  • Global employers should confirm country coverage for each search type.

Employment background check options compared

For a standard employment background check, both cover the familiar ground: criminal record searches, identity checks, driving records, drug testing, and employment and education verification. Sterling’s list adds fingerprinting, executive investigations and due diligence work. Checkr’s list adds fraud detection for identities and resumes, healthcare sanctions checks and social media searches.

Hiring manager at a desk with a laptop during screening, checkr vs sterling workflow

Neither list tells you how a search is fulfilled in your state or county, so ask each vendor how it reaches court records where you hire.

Check Best Deals on Checkr

Background check turnaround time: what each one claims

Speed is hard to compare fairly, because background check turnaround time depends on the counties and verifications involved. Checkr reports that 97% of surveyed customers found it faster than their previous vendor, and it says automated tools can cut manual review by up to 85%. First Advantage, Sterling’s parent, says about 90% of its US criminal screens close in one day. These are vendor figures, so request sample timelines for your own locations.

How ats integrations shape the daily workflow

Recruiters live inside their applicant tracking system, which makes ats integrations a practical test. Checkr states 200+ pre-built integrations with HR systems, plus an API and a mobile-first candidate flow. Sterling lists integrations, an API, candidate and client portals, and reporting tools. Confirm that your exact system is supported before you sign.

  1. List the checks each role requires by law and by policy.
  2. Ask both vendors for timelines in the counties where you hire.
  3. Confirm the integration with your ATS in a live demo.
  4. Review how each handles candidate disputes and adverse action notices.
  5. Ask Sterling contacts which First Advantage platform your account would run on.

Related guides

Frequently Asked Questions

Short answers to what employers ask when weighing these two names.

Ques: Is Sterling still a separate company?

No. First Advantage acquired it in a deal completed on October 31, 2024, and the Sterling site now describes it as a First Advantage company.

Ques: Which one suits a small business?

Checkr publishes self-serve packages online, which suits teams that want to start without a long sales process. Larger or regulated employers may prefer a tailored program.

Ques: Do both offer international checks?

Yes. Checkr states coverage in 200+ countries and territories, and Sterling lists global checks. Available searches vary by local law.

Ques: Can a screening company make the hiring decision for me?

No. The vendor supplies the report. The employer decides and must follow the notice steps the law requires before turning a candidate down.

Check Best Deals on Checkr

Bottom line

Checkr gives employers published packages, wide integrations and automation-first review under one independent roof. Sterling brings deep experience in regulated and global hiring, now delivered inside First Advantage. Pick Checkr for fast, self-serve setup, and talk to Sterling’s team if you need a tailored enterprise program and are comfortable with the new parent.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE