Checkr vs First Advantage: Key Differences in Employment Screening Services

Hiring meeting with a laptop and candidate paperwork, checkr vs first advantage screening

Two names come up in almost every screening shortlist, and they were built in different eras. The question of checkr vs first advantage is a choice between a software-first company founded in 2014 and a long-established global firm that grew larger by acquiring Sterling. This guide sets out what each one publishes so HR teams can compare like with like.

This is an independent editorial review. Checkr did not review or approve this article, and other brands are named only as reference points.

Comparison table: Checkr and First Advantage

Point Checkr First Advantage
Background Software-first screening company founded in 2014 Global screening firm that acquired Sterling in 2024
Customers stated 140,000+ businesses 80,000+ customers worldwide
How it is packaged Basic, Essential, Complete and Enterprise tiers Offerings grouped by business size, from small to global
Global reach stated 200+ countries and territories 200+ countries and territories
Integrations stated 200+ pre-built HR system integrations 100+ ATS and HCM partners
Onboarding Form I-9 as an add-on Form I-9, E-Verify and tax credit services
Post-hire Continuous checks with real-time alerts Criminal, driving, healthcare sanction and social monitoring

How checkr vs first advantage differ in approach

The split in checkr vs first advantage is mostly about how you buy and run the service. Checkr shows its packages openly and lets a team sign up online, with an API and dashboard for ordering and tracking reports. First Advantage organizes its offer by company size and industry, with separate programs for enterprise, global, contractor and student screening.

Both describe their platforms as AI-powered. Checkr ties that to report review and fraud detection, while First Advantage points to fraud detection and less manual work across the hiring cycle.

Employment screening services each one lists

The core employment screening services overlap heavily: criminal record searches, driving records, drug testing, and employment, education and license verification. First Advantage adds fingerprinting, investigative research, occupational health and random drug program management. Checkr adds resume fraud detection, healthcare sanctions checks and transportation checks for regulated drivers.

  • Check that each role’s legal requirements are covered by name.
  • Ask which searches are run in-house and which use partners.
  • Request a sample report to judge how readable the results are.

International background checks and global hiring

Both vendors say their international background checks reach more than 200 countries and territories. The headline number matters less than the detail, since the searches allowed differ by country. First Advantage notes that availability depends on local requirements, and the same caution applies to any provider. Ask for the list of checks offered in each country where you recruit.

Resume held up during an interview, checkr vs first advantage verification step

Large employers with staff in many regions may lean toward the vendor whose local teams and data rules match their footprint.

Check Best Deals on Checkr

Identity verification before the check starts

A report is only useful if it belongs to the right person, which is why identity verification now sits at the front of the process. First Advantage promotes identity solutions across the employee lifecycle and says a check can begin in about 30 seconds. Checkr includes identity verification from its Essential package upward and adds identity and resume fraud detection.

Continuous monitoring after the hire

Screening no longer ends on day one, and continuous monitoring is where the two differ in breadth. Checkr offers continuous checks that alert employers to changes in a worker’s record. First Advantage lists post-hire monitoring for criminal records, motor vehicle records, healthcare sanctions and social media, plus managed drug and alcohol programs.

  1. Map the checks you need before hire, at onboarding and after hire.
  2. Compare integration lists against the HR systems you already use.
  3. Ask each vendor for turnaround data in your hiring locations.
  4. Confirm country-by-country coverage if you recruit abroad.
  5. Review contract length and how add-on checks are billed.

Related guides

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers for teams comparing the two vendors.

Ques: Is First Advantage bigger than Checkr?

They measure size differently. First Advantage cites 80,000+ customers and 200M+ screens a year, while Checkr cites 140,000+ businesses. Neither number tells you which fits your hiring.

Ques: Does First Advantage own Sterling?

Yes. It completed the acquisition of Sterling on October 31, 2024, and Sterling’s site now directs visitors to First Advantage.

Ques: Which is easier to start with?

Checkr allows online sign-up with listed packages. First Advantage generally begins with a conversation about your company size and needs.

Ques: Do both handle Form I-9?

Checkr lists Form I-9 among its add-ons. First Advantage lists Form I-9 together with E-Verify under onboarding.

Check Best Deals on Checkr

Bottom line

Checkr suits employers that want transparent packages, a wide integration list and a quick start. First Advantage suits organizations that need a broad pre-hire to post-hire program with onboarding and compliance services attached. Shortlist both, then let your own roles, locations and systems decide.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE