A potter with twenty mugs to sell has two big doors to knock on, and they open onto very different rooms. Comparing etsy vs amazon handmade is a comparison of two business models: a marketplace built around small creative shops, and a handmade section inside the largest general store on the internet. This guide looks at how each one works for makers and what that means for shoppers.
This is an independent editorial review. Etsy did not review or approve this article, and other brands are named only as reference points.
Comparison table: the two models
| Point | Etsy | Amazon Handmade |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A marketplace for handmade goods, vintage items and craft supplies | A handmade category inside Amazon |
| Who can sell | Anyone who opens a shop and follows the seller policies | Makers who apply and are approved |
| Fee structure | A listing fee per item plus a percentage of each sale and payment processing | A referral percentage on each sale, with no listing fee |
| Shop identity | Named shop with banner, story and policies | Maker profile inside the standard Amazon layout |
| Shipping | Seller ships, with optional label tools | Seller ships, or Amazon fulfills from its warehouses |
| Buyer mindset | Looking for unique or custom items | Looking for convenience and fast delivery |
How etsy vs amazon handmade differ at the core
The starting ideas are opposite. Etsy began as a home for crafters and grew outward. Amazon began as a general store and added a curated corner for artisans. In etsy vs amazon handmade, one site treats the maker’s shop as the product, and the other treats the item as the product and the maker as a detail on the page.
What an etsy shop gives a maker
Opening an etsy shop is quick, and the shop is yours to shape. You write the story, set processing times, define return rules and message buyers directly. Shoppers can follow a shop and come back to it, which helps repeat business.
- Easy to start with a handful of listings.
- Strong for personalized and made-to-order work.
- Crowded categories, so photos and search wording matter.
How amazon handmade is set up
To sell on amazon handmade, a maker applies and describes how the products are produced. Approved sellers list inside the normal Amazon catalog and can use Amazon’s own warehouses for storage and delivery. That puts handmade goods in front of a vast audience and allows fast shipping, but the page looks like every other Amazon page and the maker has less room to stand out.

How etsy seller fees compare in structure
We are leaving out the numbers on purpose, because both companies change them. The shape is what matters. With etsy seller fees, a maker pays a small charge to list each item, then a percentage when it sells, plus payment processing, and may pay more for advertising. Amazon’s handmade program charges nothing to list and takes a larger percentage of each sale. A seller with many slow-moving listings feels the first model, and a seller with high sales volume feels the second.
- List every fee that applies: listing, sale, payment and advertising.
- Work out the total on a typical order, including shipping charged to the buyer.
- Compare that total across both sites using current published rates.
- Recheck once a year, since rates change.
Which handmade marketplace suits which buyer
For shoppers, the better handmade marketplace depends on the purchase. If you want something engraved, sized or made to a brief, a site built on direct messages with the maker is the natural fit. If you want a ready-made handmade gift delivered quickly with a familiar checkout, the Amazon route is convenient. Many makers sell on both, so it is worth searching a shop name on each.
Related guides
- Personalized vs Ready Made Gifts: Etsy’s Rules
- Budget Home Decor vs Designer Home Decor at Marshalls
Frequently Asked Questions
Direct answers for makers and buyers choosing between the two.
Ques: Is everything on Etsy handmade?
No. The site also allows vintage items and craft supplies, and sellers may work with production partners under its rules. Read the listing details.
Ques: Is it harder to get approved on Amazon Handmade?
There is an application step that asks about your making process, so it takes longer than opening a shop elsewhere.
Ques: Can a maker sell on both?
Yes. Many do, keeping custom work on one site and ready-to-ship items on the other.
Ques: Which is cheaper for buyers?
Prices are set by each seller. The same maker may price differently on each site to cover different fees, so compare the final total with shipping.
Bottom line
Etsy is a shop-first marketplace that favors custom work and maker identity, and Amazon Handmade is an item-first program that favors reach and fast delivery. Makers should compare total fees on a real order, and buyers should pick by how much contact with the maker the purchase needs.

